Archive
The Redskins Win in McNabb’s Return to Philly by Lloyd Vance
Redskins QB Donovan McNabb received the game-ball for his triumphant return to Philadelphia that produced a 17-12 win for the ‘Skins
It wasn’t Picasso, but it was the best of both worlds for Redskins quarterback Donovan McNabb in his Philadelphia homecoming. The game started with the Philadelphia faithful saluting their former hero when he was announced — ironically he was loudly “booed” when he took the field under center — then like he had done 11 years prior, McNabb found a way to win.
The Redskins (2-2) took home a big 17-12 win over the Eagles (2-2) to take sole possesion of first place in the NFC East. McNabb’s numbers showed that he did not have one of his best games statistically (8-19, 125 yards, 1 TD, and 1INT plus 39 rushing yards). But it was his intangibles of leadership and moving the sticks when needed that mattered most.
When the game was on the line, Big 5 converted a crucial first down by scampering for 18 yards on a 3rd and 4 play to help wind the clock. The win had to be glorifying for McNabb, but after the game he really was focused more on a team win and the Redskins next opponent, rather than passing out “I told you so” comments.
The Redskins knew they could run the ball on the Eagles smallish defensive front and they were successful as they produced 169 yards rushing. Leading the way was Ryan Torain with 70 yards and a bruising 12-yard touchdown run, where he trucked Eagles safety Quintin Mikell and veteran Clinton Portis who added 55 rushing yards before leaving with a groin injury.
An unfortunate part of the Eagles-Redskins games was that a highly anticipated McNabb-Vick showdown turned into the McNabb-Kolb after Vick left the game in the first quarter with a rib/chest injury — hurt on a 23-yard run that was called back on a Max Jean-Giles penalty. As for Kolb, he seem rather “tentative in my opinion as he went for checkdowns several times rather than throwing the ball downfield.
An odd play that showed the Eagles glaring weakness with clock managment was at the Redskins’ 1-yard line in the final minute of the first half. After Head Coach Andy Reid called a timeout, his offense still got called for delay of game on a crucial 4th down. To the dismay of the Eagles’ sellout crowd, the Birds settled for a David Akers 23-yarder to cut the score to 17-6.
Reid tried to explain the strange series of events after the game by saying, “We had a play called. I wasn’t surprised the clock was moving, but I was surprised it was moving as quick as when it was started with the spot”.
However the game was not over until the very last play when Kolb threw a “Hail Mary” pass into the Eagles endzone that bounced out of receiver Jason Avant’s hands and was intercepted by DeAngelo Hall.
McNabb said after the game, “It’s about winning ballgames, and that’s one that I take pride in.”
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
Reid Makes the Right Decision in Choosing Vick by Lloyd Vance
The Philadelphia Eagles QB Controversy took a crazy turn as head coach Andy Reid named Michael Vick as his starter for the rest of the 2010 season
In a shocking and quite bizarre change of events, Philadelphia Eagles head coach Andy Reid did a total 360-degree about face by naming comebacking quarterback Michael Vick to be his starter for he rest of the 2010 season. Reid said in a September 21st press conference to announce the change, “Michael Vick will be the starting quarterback for the Philadelphia Eagles. I think his play has even exceeded expectations over the last two weeks.”
Of course in naming Vick the starter, Reid who has notoriously been quite stubborn over his 12 years in Philadelphia –- see former receivers that he told us were good enough…when we all knew they weren’t (i.e. Pinkston, Thrash, Mitchell) — definitely had to back track on his anointing of former starter, Kevin Kolb, who had been the team’s face since an Easter Sunday 2010 trade of 11-year veteran Donovan McNabb. The 4th year quarterback and first-time starter had been given a lucrative extension on April 29th with the terms 1-year, 12.26 million through 2011 with all of it guaranteed and $10.7 million in a signing bonus. Reid even said when Kolb signed his new deal, “When given the chance, Kevin has proven to have good command of this offense and we’re looking forward to having him operate as the number one quarterback for the Philadelphia Eagles”.
I guess the coach misremembered his comments from April and a couple of days prior, because now Vick is his guy. Reid tried to soften the blow to Kolb by saying, “This has nothing to do with Kevin Kolb’s injury. Kevin Kolb has done a phenomenal job for us here and the future of Kevin Kolb is not slighted by this one bit. He has an opportunity, obviously, to be, what I would consider, a franchise quarterback and deserving of so.” In trying to further justify his decision Reid added, “Again, this is more about Michael Vick and his accelerated play. He’s sitting there as possibly the hottest quarterback in the National Football League at this time and deserves an opportunity to play. It also allows Kevin to continue as a young quarterback in the National Football League, his maturation process, and, again, to become a franchise quarterback in the future.”
Alright before we try to get in the mind of Coach Reid and understand why he flip-flopped in a matter of 3 Days, we have to first jump in the hot tub time machine and go over the events that led to the firestorm of activity around the Birds’ quarterbacks. Let’s go back to Sunday September 19th around 5:00 PM EST; the Eagles had pulled off a hard-earned 35-32 win over the scrappy Detroit Lions. Where backup quarterback Michael Vick, who was making his first NFL start since December 31, 2006, for the second week in a row had given the Eagles a noticeable spark as Kolb recovered from a concussion suffered against the Green Bay Packers in Week 1. The former 3-time Pro Bowl player was sensational as he made something out of nothing several times, both in and out of the pocket, in the win over the Lions. Vick finished with numbers 21-for-34 for 284 yards passing and two TD tosses, with 37 yards rushing plus he withstood being sacked 6 times behind a porous Eagles’ offensive line.
Almost immediately after my hometown Eagles put the final touches on a good win that put them at 1-1 and we later learned a tie for first place in the NFC East, my cell phone started going crazy. I didn’t even need to answer a single call or read one text message. Because I knew the “vocal” majority of the Birds’ fan base –- the same ones that wanted McNabb gone and for Kevin Kolb to take over… but I digress — had now switched their allegiance to Vick. However almost immediately into his post-game press conference, Reid tried to squelch any Vick talk by saying that his now-healthy Week 1 starter, Kolb (concussion), would be returning as the team’s starting quarterback next week against the Jacksonville Jaguars in Week 3. Can you say, “Quarterback Controversy”? The move was both lauded and loudly questioned on post-game radio, television and Twitter in the Philadelphia area and nationally.
To Vick’s credit, he showed that he had moved on from his former selfish ways that plagued him during his time with the Atlanta Falcons by supporting his teammate. Of the whole Kolb-Vick quarterback controversy brewing in Philly, Vick stepped away from the grenade by humbly saying, “This is Kevin’s team”. Vick added, “All I wanted to do was come out and get the momentum going. I’m sure Kevin will be back next week.” But you had to think that deep down after all he had been through that even Vick -– career passing numbers 973-1801, 54.0%, 12050 yards, 75 TDs, and 52 INTs with additional rushing numbers of 4094 yards, 7.2 ypr, and 23 TDs — knew that he “deserved” to get his shot back in the spotlight. As incredibly as it sounds, the player once described as “Public Enemy No. 1” in the minds of many NFL fans had done the unthinkable, going from a hated reputed dogfighter to a playmaker.
C’mon not even Hollywood could have written a better script. The long redemption road that the former Virginia Tech star had traveled since his last start in December 2006 has been a well-documented rollercoaster, to say the least. Vick’s road back to NFL glory included an 18-month stay in Leavenworth Prison for his role in a dogfighting ring and a getting-to-know-you 2009 season where he served as a spare part Eagles’ third-stringer –- only threw 13 passes, completing 6 for 86 yards and 1 TD. But now he was back to the player that once had the NFL buzzing back when he led the Falcons to a mission-impossible 27-7 win over the Green Bay Packers at snowy Lambeau Field in the Wildcard round of the 2002 NFL Playoffs. Surprisingly 8 years later, his 4.3 speed was back and he also added another piece to his repertoire by showing the vision needed to make passes downfield from the pocket. Even Reid couldn’t help talking about Vick’s eye-opening effort in the win over the Lions, which unfortunately for Kolb, probably forced his hand in naming Vick the starter. Reid said after the Lions win about Vick, “You’re talking about a phenomenal football player who’s had another chance to prove himself…To see the sparkle in his eye is amazing.”
Call me “crazy”, but Vick –- salary of $3.75 million in 2010 plus an already paid $1.5 million roster bonus — has bought into Reid and offensive coordinator Marty Mornhinweg’s coaching enough that now he looks like Donovan McNabb circa 2000. That season the Eagles made the playoffs for the first time under Reid by finishing 11-5 even though they were a very young team. Back then the Eagles relied heavily on their dual-threat quarterback and McNabb produced passing (over 3,000 yards), and rushing (over 600 yards) while accounting for 27 touchdowns (21 passing and 6 rushing)…Does any of this sound familiar. In two weeks of play in 2010, Vick –-passing numbers through 2 weeks of 37-58, 63.8%, 459 yards, 3 TDs, and 0 INTs with a career-high passer rating of 105.5 plus 140 rushing yards — has knocked off several years of rust to become Reid’s type of starting quarterback. He no longer is settling for his first read then taking off to make spectacular running plays only, Vick is a passer first…if you can believe it. The exciting thing is that the Eagles have responded under Vick’s leadership by putting up 52 points in six quarters.
Reid recently said in a press conference that he now is in the enviable spot of having “Two Quality” quarterbacks. But give me break coach…you can spin it anyway you want, the reality of the situation is that Kolb -– career passing numbers of 84-140, 60.0%, 909 yards, 4 TDs, and 7 INTs with a 1-2 starting record –- was not the “right” guy for the 2010 Philadelphia Eagles. I know that sounds harsh after Kolb has only played in basically one half of football -– passing numbers of 5-for-10 for only 24 yards and produced only 3 first downs before the concussion knocked him out against the Packers. But today’s NFL is a “Win Now” league. Everyone from fans to the media to the team’s management are not content with having a rebuilding season when the NFC East is there for the taking. Fox Sports analyst Terry Bradshaw also believes now is the time for Vick. Bradshaw said on the network’s pregame show of the situation, “With Kolb, you’re looking at a guy who really doesn’t have a resume”. The Hall of Fame quarterback added, “He’s only started three games. I would find it very difficult for Kolb to win with the Eagles offensive line being in shambles. Vick is better suited right now to win football games than Kevin.”
The division-favorite Dallas Cowboys (0-2) are looking like they could implode at any moment and the other teams in the division, the New York Giants and Washington Redskins, don’t look like they are making reservations for Super Bowl XLV either. As always, Reid’s goal is to make the playoffs and he knew Vick was his best chance to win. Though I am not entirely ready to say the Eagles are definitely a playoff team with Vick. Who knows if the 2010 Eagles could possibly catch the same lightning in a bottle that caused the 2005 Steelers, 2007 NY Giants, and 2009 NY Jets to make to make strong playoff runs, despite having some regular season flaws.
Another deciding factor for Reid had to be an offensive line that is beat-up and sorely missing their leader, Jamaal Jackson. The Eagles’ offensive line needs to make adjustments, because as a unit they have allowed a whopping 12 sacks in two games and lost Kolb to a concussion. Vick, who has been sacked 9 times despite running from pressure, is the Eagles’ best weapon against the fast attacking defenses that have been exploiting the team’s protection breakdowns. And I won’t even go into whether the Eagles wanted to take back the Philadelphia area’s sports fans’ attention from major league baseball’s Philadelphia Phillies who look like they are surging to their 3rd World Series appearance in three years, but that is always an item for debate.
Whatever the reason for naming Vick the starter, it was the right reason for the Philadelphia Eagles to win now. Reid said of the decision to go with Vick, “This is my decision”. Reid strongly added, “Listen, when you deal with a decision like this, you take as much time as you possibly need to take and so I did that. It’s not my obligation to tell people my decision. It’s my obligation to make the proper decision. That’s why I took the time to do that.”
Good Luck coach with your new starting quarterback, because you know this quarterback controversy is not going away anytime soon… especially with the passionate fans of Philadelphia.
Wonder if Eagles fans and Reid would rather still have Big 5 still under center –- he beat Dallas in Week 1 and threw for over 400 yards in a loss to the Texans in Week 2…..Alright I won’t go there.
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
2010 NFL Week 1 Review by Lloyd Vance
The Seattle Seahawks, fueled by comebacking receiver Mike Williams (pictured), dominated the favored San Francisco 49ers by a score of 31-6 in one of Week 1′s bigger upsets
The first weekend of the 91st NFL season titled: “The Grand Crossroads of Hope” is finally over. NFL nation just couldn’t get enough of America’s Game as Week 1 stretched over three game days (September 9th, September 12th, and September 13th). Even in the face of pending CBA Doom, fans turned out in record numbers as even the downtrodden Jacksonville Jaguars played to a sellout – only one of the NFL’s slate of 16 games, the Tampa Bay Bucs – Cleveland Browns in Tampa, FL was blacked out.
Overall the first week of the 2010 NFL season brought surprises (Houston Texans led by RB Arian Foster dominating the Colts, Chiefs taking out the Chargers in the 2nd MNF game, Seahawks pounding Niners who were supposed to be the NFC West favorites and several photo finishes), non-surprises (Bills finding a way to lose again, Steelers and Ravens winning “ugly” behind running the ball and attacking defense), cheers, and tears (Sorry Detroit Lions fans…Megatron did indeed catch that touchdown no matter what the officials say) that only NFL drama can provoke. The wins and losses no doubt will create a buzz of “Monday Morning Quarterbacking” around the water cooler and on sports radio, but remember the NFL season is a 16 game marathon. To the NFL’s credit, the majority of Week 1 games (11 out 16) were decided by 7 points or less.
The first game on Thursday night kicked off the excitement (fireworks, Grammy winners, etc) and featured the Super Bowl champion New Orleans Saints using a fast start by their offense to hold off the Minnesota Vikings 14-9. In the game you could see a couple of things: The Saints offensive line is physical and can run the ball when needed (didn’t hear Jared Allen’s name called once), Vikings QB Brett Favre looked extremely rusty as he threw a bad interception and couldn’t rally his team in the 4th quarter, and New Orleans probably has the NFL’s highest octane offense even if they were stuck in neutral for parts of the opener.
What I love about Week 1 is experts, fans, and some members of the media start making year-long assertions based on “one week” of real NFL games. Two of the comments/feedback that I have received after only one week of play that I consider “laughable” from one of my loyal listeners were: “After the way the Texans beat-up Indianapolis, Peyton Manning and the Colts are done…It is going to be a long year in Indy”; “The Philadelphia Eagles have to start Michael Vick because Kevin Kolb will never get it done” and “The Baltimore Ravens are this year’s Super Bowl champs based on their physical play”. Just slow your roll there a little bit “Mr. Overzealous Fan”.
C’mon some of these conclusions may prove to be true, but Week 1 isn’t enough game action to paint with such a broad picture. Sure Week 1 is important for setting the tone for the entire season — the last 44 Super Bowl Champions started out a combined 36-7-1 in Week 1 of their championship season and teams that made the playoffs last year were a combined 10-2 in 2009’s Week 1. But remember in the parity-laden NFL everything can change very quickly. The theme that I will continue to pound at this time of year is that an NFL season is a marathon and should be taken increments. Being on top early in an NFL season guarantees nothing. Teams can’t get caught up in thinking things are going to be biscuits and gravy throughout the entire season. The main thing right now is for teams to focus week-in and week-out on the team that they are facing. Last year after five weeks the NY Giants looked like Super Bowl contenders as they started 5-0 only to limp home to an 8-8 record.
Some Lloyd’s Leftovers from Week 1 included:
A Bad Rule Rears its Ugly Head – And you thought “Tuck” rule that thwarted the Raiders years ago was bad. The hard-luck Detroit Lions were jobbed by a rule that doesn’t pass the smell test in my opinion. In a game that was there’s for the taking, the Lions had fought through losing starter Matthew Stafford and were poised to beat their NFC North rival, the Chicago Bears. With 1:32 remaining in the game, backup Shaun Hill threw a great 25-yard apparent touchdown Calvin “Megatron” Johnson. Unfortunately after one official called touchdown, the zebras huddled and Johnson’s catch was ruled incomplete due to the big receiver not maintaining possession throughout his catch according to the officials….Bogus. I have even listed the cockamamie rule for you to interpret — “If a player goes to the ground in the act of catching a pass (with or without contact by an opponent), he must maintain control of the ball after he touches the ground, whether in the field of play or the end zone. If he loses control of the ball, and the ball touches the ground before he regains control, the pass is incomplete. If he regains control prior to the ball touching the ground, the pass is complete.” I thought the call was a disgrace and once again, officials are making themselves part of the story…Sorry Lions fans, you deserved better.
The Ravens Show talk is cheap on MNF – After selling Wolf Tickets on HBO’s Hard Knocks, the New York Jets expected to open their $1.6 Billion Dollar home stadium in style. Unfortunately, the Jets had no idea what was in store for them. In a physical dominating win, the Baltimore Ravens, led by veteran linebacker Ray Lewis, put all of the Jets’ Hard Knocks boasting to rest as they showed the country who is the NFL’s best defense. The J-E-T-S were held to six first downs and a one-of-11 rate on third-down conversions in a black-and-blue 10-9 loss. Plus Rex Ryan’s rowdy bunch produced a staggering 14 penalties for 125 yards. Ryan said of his team’s effort, “Today, was a joke.” Lewis said of the opening-game win, “All the trash talking, it’s out the door. Every time you challenge a warrior, a warrior is going to always respond.”
The NFL Season is Survival of the Fittest– The “tough” physical game of football causes a survival of the fittest on the way to the Lombardi Trophy. No team makes it to the top without dealing with injuries every week of the season. Unfortunately one of this week’s biggest stories was two season-ending injuries for the Philadelphia Eagles as leaders center Jamaal Jackson (torn triceps) and fullback Leonard Weaver (severe knee injury) unfortunately were badly hurt. The Eagles also will be on the NFL’s front page too for another set of injuries as both QB Kevin Kolb and MLB Stewart Bradley had concussions, but were allowed to return to the field briefly before being shutdown at halftime. Now both players will have to pass baseline testing and other tests administered by an independent source before returning to game action. Other major injuries were Lions QB Matthew Stafford (Shoulder), Panthers QB Matt Moore (Concussion), Packers RB Ryan Grant (ankle), Cardinals WR Early Doucet (Hamstring), Giants TE Kevin Boss (Concussion), Texans DE Conner Barwin (fractured ankle), Colts S Bob Sanders (elbow), Steelers LT Max Starks (high ankle sprain) and NT Kris Jenkins (knee).
Colts need to get serious about the run – Sure…QB Peyton Manning had great numbers 40-57, 433 yards and 3 TDs in a 34-24 road loss. But the Colts’ lopsided loss to the Texans showed that successful teams can run the football on offense and stop the run on defense. Houston out-rushed Indy 257 to 44, setting a franchise record for most rushing yards in Texans’ franchise history and most rushing yards allowed in Colts’ franchise history.
Former playoff teams struggle – As I always say, “Every year is different in the NFL”. That phrase was never more prophetic than in Week 1 where 2009 playoff teams went a combined 5-7 — winners were Patriots, Saints, Cardinals, Packers, and Ravens. Yes… the Patriots dominated the Cincinnati Bengals 38-24.
Witherspoon shows heart – Only days after learning about his mother’s passing, Carolina Panthers LB Will Witherspoon gave everything he had in a loss to the NY Giants.
Game Balls
Houston Texans RB Arian Foster – What an amazing game for the 2nd year runner, who was viewed as a back-up just a short time ago. Foster (6’1, 220), running in OC Rick Dennison’s zone-blocking scheme, became the first player in NFL history to rush for 200+ yards and three touchdowns on Kickoff Weekend. The former Tennessee star finished with 33 carries for 231 yards — including 191 yards in the 2nd half — and 3 TDs as the Texans rushed for a franchise record 257 yards in the big 34-24 win over the Colts. The Texans maybe changing their ways into a rushing team first as shown by their 42-to-17 run-to-pass ratio in the much-celebrated win.
Honorable Mention – Chicago Bears RB Matt Forte, Green Bay Packers LB Clay Matthews Jr, Kansas City Chiefs kick returner Dexter McCluster, Tennessee Titans RB Chris Johnson, New York Giants WR Hakeem Nicks, Seattle Seahawks WR Mike Williams, New England Patriots WR Wes Welker, Pittsburgh Steelers RB Rashard Mendenhall, Houston Texans DE Mario Williams, Washington Redskins CB DeAngelo Hall and Baltimore Ravens LB Ray Lewis
Lloyd’s Lackey of the Week
Philadelphia Eagles Head Coach Andy Reid – After already quickly burning his 2nd half timeouts, with the game on the line Reid and/or offensive coordinator Marty Mornhinweg came up short. Backup QB Michael Vick had rallied the Eagles from a 17-point hole and the Birds had to convert a fourth-and-1 from the Green Bay 42-yard line with two minutes left for a chance to tie the score at 27 points. Reid decided that Vick – who lined up in the shotgun formation — should run a quarterback draw up the middle instead passing or getting the speedster to the edge. Of course, the Packers easily diagnosed the play and stuffed Vick for no gain to the ire of the Philadelphia Faithful. The 4th down play was the cherry on top of Eagles injuries, poor offensive execution in first half, poor offensive line, concussion controversies and penalties…I bet the Eagles will never wear those 1960 throwback jerseys again. Green Packers LB Nick Barnett said of the crucial 4th down play, “He’d been making all the plays, and we knew they were going to put it on him…So yeah, we were ready.”
Dishonorable Mention – The “Loudmouth” New York Jets, Officiating crew from the Bears-Lions game, Carolina Panthers QB Matt Moore, Niners RB Frank Gore, Bengals WR Terrell Owens and the Dallas Cowboys
2010 NFL Week 1
Thu, Sep 09
Saints 14, Vikings 9 — Fast start for Brees and his WR’s then a defensive battle..After missing most of camp was Favre rusty??
Sun, Sep 12
Jaguars 24, Broncos 17 — Big win for the Jags, Garrard 3 TDs
Titans 38, Raiders 13 — The Titans stomp all over the Raiders led by CJ2K who had 142 yds and 2 TDs
Patriots 38, Bengals 24 — Behind Brady and Welker, New England jumps out 24-3 in first half and cruises home. Moss bitching about contract
Bucs 17, Browns 14 — Tampa puts away the hard-luck Browns; Freeman had a good game
Texans 34, Colts 24 — Fueled by RB Arian Foster (231 yds, 3TDs) Houston rolled; QB Peyton Manning had big yards, but there were several drops
Bears 19, Lions 14 — Chicago wins a good game that was overshadowed by the officials overturning an apparent Calvin Johnson TD
Steelers 15, Falcons 9 — P-Burgh wins in OT on a Mendenhall run; Lots of D and FGs, but Steelers win on 50-yd TD run in OT
Dolphins 15, Bills 10 — Henne efficient.. Good running by R. Brown; Bills are a bad team
Giants 31, Panthers 18 — Eli and Hakim Nicks have huge days; Matt Moore (concussion) had 2 INTs in the endzone
Packers 27, Eagles 20 — Philly loses Jackson, Kolb, Bradley, and Weaver; Back-up Vick starts a QB controversy as he almost gets it done
Cardinals 17, Rams 13 — The Cardinals return to STL and get an ugly win; Though hurting, WR Larry Fitzgerald had the game-winner
Seahawks 31, SF49ers 6 — Hasselbeck has a big day and the Niners look bad; Singletary has some clean-up to do
Redskins 13, Cowboys 7 — McNabb efficient and Defense scores TD; Romo throws touchdown at end that is disallowed due to Barron’s holding penalty
Mon, Sep 13
Ravens 10, NY Jets 9 — Ray Lewis and his defense show the J-E-T-S that “talk” is cheap; Also NY Jets QB Mark Sanchez has to do better than 71 yards passing
Chiefs 21, Chargers 14 — Stayed up late for this one, but it was worth it; Romeo Crennel’s young defense came-up big when it mattered most; KC has some speedsters too
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
Breaking Down John Clayton’s 2010 NFL QB Rankings by Lloyd Vance
Atlanta Falcons QB Matt Ryan is ranked as the 13th best quarterback in the NFL by ESPN’s John Clayton, but he should be higher…in my humble opinion
If I have said it once, I have said it 1,000 times…”The NFL is a quarterback driven league”. So one of my favorite past times is comparing league quarterbacks against each other. And this year, ESPN’s John Clayton helped further the debate by recently posting his annual quarterback rankings. Clayton broke down the league’s starters into 3 divisions (The Elite, The “Chad Pennington” Division – i.e. “Caretakers”, and Hit-Or-Miss).
As usual the Professor did a nice job in weaving stats, analysis, and opinion. But it would not be any fun if I didn’t poke any holes into his rankings. Though I don’t have many contentions, I definitely think Clayton should have used my favorite quarterback barometer, Playoff Wins, more.
- I think the Elite Division should only be Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Brett Favre, and Ben Roethlisberger. These quarterbacks have gotten it done in postseason (i.e. Super Bowl winners) and they also have had great stats for more than 5 years.
- There needs to be another division called “Fantasy Footballers”. These are quarterbacks that have put up big stats in the regular season, but have not yet sustained postseason success. Heck a couple of them haven’t even made it to the postseason or won one playoff game. This group would be Matt Schaub (no playoff appearances), Aaron Rodgers (no playoff wins), Jay Cutler (no playoff appearances), Tony Romo (playoff record of 1-3), and Carson Palmer (playoff record of 0-2 with both losses at home).
- Another division also needing to be created is “The Old Heads”. These are good quarterbacks that are a 5-year plus veterans that have had some success in the past. I will put Donovan McNabb in this group — despite his 9-7 playoff record – but he can’t be considered “Elite” without the ring. You can also add Philip Rivers — sorry San Diego fans…this 3-time Pro Bowler has a career 3-4 playoff record — Matt Hasselbeck and Eli Manning. I know Archie’s youngest has a Super Bowl ring, but he also is a “team” quarterback that has only one 4,000-yard passing season and one 25+ touchdown season on his mantle -– both in 2009.
- The “Young Guns”, who are quarterbacks working their way up. I know some of them have already had some playoff success, but it is still too early to draw long term predictions. This group would include Matt Ryan, Joe Flacco, Vince Young, Kevin Kolb, Chad Henne, Mark Sanchez, Josh Freeman, Matthew Stafford, Matt Cassel and Sam Bradford.
- No list would be complete without a group called “The Journeymen”. These are guys just happy to be called a starter…well for now. Byron Leftwich, Matt Leinart / Derek Anderson, Matt Moore, Jake Delhomme, David Garrard, Alex Smith, Jason Campbell, Trent Edwards, and Kyle Orton — Don’t let his 29-19 starting record or last year’s almost 4,000-yard passing season fool you.
Here is my ranking list for the NFL’s marquee position
1) Peyton Manning
2) Drew Brees
3) Tom Brady
4) Ben Roethlisberger
5) Brett Favre
6) Philip Rivers
7) Aaron Rodgers
8) Donovan McNabb
9) Matt Ryan
10) Joe Flacco
11) Tony Romo
12) Carson Palmer
13) Eli Manning
14) Matt Schaub
15) Vince Young
16) Jay Cutler
17) Matthew Stafford
18) Kyle Orton
19) David Garrard
20) Jason Campbell
21) Kevin Kolb
22) Matt Hasselbeck
23) Mark Sanchez
24) Chad Henne
25) Matt Cassel
26) Alex Smith
27) Byron Leftwich
28) Matt Moore
29) Josh Freeman
30) Sam Bradford
31) Michael Vick
32) Jimmy Clausen
33) Derek Anderson / Matt Leinart
34) Trent Edwards
35) Jake Delhomme
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
2010 NFL Preseason Week 1 Review by Lloyd Vance
Steelers QB Dennis Dixon received a Game Ball for his outstanding play in Week 1 of the 2010 NFL Preseason
Week 1 of the 2010 NFL Preseason is now in the books. As usual the start of preseason games are welcomed by most players (want to hit someone else other than teammates) and fans (“Jonesing” for their football fix). But after most of the starters have left preseason games, usually in the first or second quarter, everyone watching can’t wait for the “real” games to start. Unfortunately there are usually several “training camp” players on the field after halftime, which lends to some sloppy play at times.
The week’s highlight had to be the opening of the New Meadowlands Stadium as the “Battle for New York” was center stage on Monday Night football. Friendly tenants, the New York Giants and New York Jets, battled it out with the G-Men coming away with a 31-16 win. The biggest television-worth play had to be Giants quarterback Eli Manning having a “Y.A Tittle” moment. Manning departed the game in the first half with a three-inch laceration to his forehead after getting caught between two Jets’ defenders with his helmet off. Blood was gushing from Peyton’s little brother’s melon, which definitely needed several stitches to close the wound.
One key element that I noticed this week and throughout the preseason is that the National Football League is “survival of the fittest”, where you can never have too much quality depth. Unfortunately players around the league continue to drop like flies. Some notable injuries were Buffalo Bills RB Fred Jackson (broken hand – 4 to 6 weeks), Houston Texans RB Ben Tate (broken ankle – season), Tennessee Titans RB Stafon Johnson (his great comeback story is over for now after a heart-breaking ankle injury), Dallas Cowboys OT Marco Colombo (knee scoped), Detroit Lions LB Jordon Dizon (knee – season), New England Patriots DE Ty Warren (season-ending hip injury), Baltimore Ravens OT Jared Gaither (back tear) and too many others to list.
All these injuries are making coaches and general managers scream, “Please Let’s Just Start the Regular Season”. I have to agree with them, because too often important pieces of a team’s puzzle are lost for considerable amounts of time, including for the entire season, in meaningless games. We all know that preseason games — or “exhibition” games as I like to call them — are only on the schedule for the purpose of generating extra revenue (television dollars and local teams having two extra “home” games at full price) and they are very unnecessary. Also as Eagles head coach Andy Reid recently said of his game-planning for the his preseason Week 1 opponent, the Jacksonville Jaguars, “We kept it pretty vanilla” – BTW: the Eagles and Jaguars play in Week 3 of the regular season. You just are not going to see much in preseason as teams usually want to save their best for the games that count.
With today’s athletes already engaging in year-round NFL activities including OTAs and long arduous training camps, four preseason games is a bit much. Today’s NFL players’ bodies are already pushed to the max after training camp two-a-days in the hot sun, so there is already a “Next Man Up” mentality before preseason games are even played. I know coaches try to limit exposure to key veterans by getting them out of preseason games early, but the risk is always there. I believe NFL commissioner Roger Goodell needs to investigate limiting preseason game, however I am not sure about removing them just to add more career-shortening regular season games.
Even though this week’s preseason games only gave a minor taste of “real” regular season NFL football action, there were some bright spot performances. Overall though, I say bring on the “real” games, because the NFL’s preseason is just too long of a process and watching games of depth chart 3’s versus 4’s is unbearable. For goodness sakes, Minnesota Vikings 3rd string quarterback Sage Rosenfels threw for 310 yards and 3 TDs in a 28-7 win over the hapless St. Louis Rams ….need I say anymore.
Game Balls
Redskins QB Donovan McNabb – After a slow start, Washington’s new signal-caller settled down to lead his offensive unit to touchdown. McNabb hit young receiver Anthony Armstrong with a 4-yard strike to complete his night’s work. For the game, Big 5 finished with numbers 5-of-8 for 58 yards in two series.
Giants WR Victor Cruz – I guess the NY Jets really do need holdout Darrelle Revis. A preseason star was born in the Giants’ 31-16 win over the NY Jets. Cruz caught 6 passes for 145 yards and 3 TDs.
Packers QB Aaron Rodgers – The former 2009 Pro Bowl passer was amazing as he finished with numbers of 12-13, 159 yards, and 1 TD against the lowly Cleveland Browns.
Panthers QB Jimmy Clausen – Could there be a quarterback controversy in Carolina already?? I am saying hold your horses on that one. But the former Notre Dame star showed good footwork and arm strength in his team’s 17-12 loss to the Ravens.
Steelers QB Dennis Dixon — Had a perfect passer rating as he finished with numbers 6-7, 128 yards and 1 TD in a 23-7 win over the Detroit Lions.
Panthers OLB Greg Hardy – Showed great burst off the edge as he finished with 2 sacks in a loss to the Ravens
Lloyd’s Lackey
Colts better get another back-up quarterback – Usually try to not give out a “Lloyd’s Lackey” this time of the year. But there was an awful performance that must be noted. In case Peyton Manning gets hurt — not that No. 18 ever gets hurt — Indy has no shot of winning games with back-up passer Curtis Painter. The former Purdue star was awful in a 37-17 loss to the San Francisco 49ers. His line for the game was 9-for-19, 64 yards, 0 TDs, and 3 INTs.
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
My View from the Washington Redskins Press Box by Lake Lewis
Optimism is all that any Washington Redskins’ fan can ever hope for after a horrid 2009 football campaign. Last season contained former Redskins head coach Jim Zorn — now Baltimore Ravens quarterbacks coach — routinely questioned by fans and the media for his coaching tactics. Former starting quarterback Jason Campbell’s leadership was questioned and many debated if he even was a legitimate playoff caliber signal caller. And lastly, the ‘Skins defense was often criticized for not playing in a free-flowing attacking style.
Well, the 2010 season has brought eternal hope for all around our Nation’s Capital. And if last night’s Redskins preseason opener against the Buffalo Bills was any indicator, then the new season should bring a sort of giddiness seldom bestowed on this franchise over the last decade. The Redskins came out and imposed their will on the Buffalo Bills in route to a 42-17 alley-slapping.
In the Redskins’ preseason opening win, the three most important off-season acquisitions, in my opinion, of Head Coach Mike Shanahan, Offensive Coordinator Kyle Shanahan, and Quarterback Donovan McNabb did not disappoint in their burgundy and gold debuts – BTW: I didn’t count General Manager Bruce Allen as he joined the team at the end of the 2009 season.
After a shaky first series, the Redskins’ offense -– 2009 NFL rankings of 22nd in total offense and 26th in scoring — showed signs of life. On their second possession, the new look offense led by McNabb orchestrated a twelve play, 70-yard, drive culminating with the former All-Pro passer connecting with first-year player Anthony Armstrong on a four-yard touchdown strike. The touchdown pass showed that finally the Redskins seem to have the most important position on the field covered.
McNabb’s improvisation skills were on full display on the touchdown play as he showed foot movement and presence in the pocket. The former Philadelphia Eagles starter kept the play alive by moving around to find his receiver despite some pressure from the Bills. Overall, McNabb who took the snap from center 17 times — was scheduled to take only 18 snaps actually — completed five of eight passes for 58 yards and the aforementioned touchdown. The former 6-time Pro Bowl player also turned in a more than respectable 124.0 quarterback rating for the game.
In his postgame presser, McNabb said that he felt good after having played his first game with the Redskins. The new leader of Washington’s offense said, “It was an exciting time. When you play your first game, obviously, with a new ball club it takes you back to the first game you played.” The 12-year veteran added, “Your adrenaline is high and you have to settle down a little bit. The second time we went out, after our first drive, it led us putting up some points. Then good things happen. There are a lot of things we have to work on but I thought offensively we were able to progress today.”
The strong performance of the Redskins did not stop at McNabb’s doorstep. Back-up quarterback Rex Grossman, a former Super Bowl lead guy in Chicago, may have helped ease any discord about who will replace #5 should he have any kind of setback. Grossman showed complete command of the Kyle Shanahan’s offense, which he was already familiar with from having been coached by the younger Shanahan last year with the Houston Texans. For the game, Grossman played two quarters while completing eleven passes for 140 yards and 2 touchdowns. The former Florida Gators passer also finished with a great quarterback rating too (122.5).
One of the recipients of Grossman’s two touchdown passes was gifted receiver Devin Thomas. The former Michigan State receiver had recently been under intense scrutiny for his participation in a music video with R&B star Fantasia. But he rebounded to have a nice game as he pulled-in three catches for 64 yards and a touchdown. Some people, who I talked to during the game, thought that Thomas should be bypassing any outside distractions and just focusing on football.
However Thomas showed why he was a top-rated receiver prospect on many boards back during the 2008 draft. Yesterday’s game could be the confidence booster for Shanahan’s offense and the third-year pro that the Redskins have been looking for. After briefly talking to Thomas after the game, I can safely say there is not a more engaging player who knows exactly what is expected of him in the locker room. I truly expect a breakout year for the developing receiver and for Thomas to also be the starter opposite veteran Santana Moss come opening day.
On the defensive side of the ball, there were some things from the game that I believe need to be corrected including over-pursuit and poor tackling. But for the most part, new defensive coordinator Jim Hasslet’s unit showed the attacking style that most Washington fans have longed for since the departure of former defensive coordinator Gregg Williams, who is now with the Super Bowl champion New Orleans Saints. The other major off-season drama, the Albert Haynesworth situation, also definitely seems to have been put to bed. The $100-million dollar man started his long climb back up the depth charts and ‘Skins Nation’s hearts by playing a solid game. Haynesworth entered the game in the second quarter, with the second unit, and although he did not record a sack or a tackle, his presence helped several players.
Redskins Game Notes:
First-year players who made an impact on the game were:
— LB Perry Riley who played well and was credited with a tackle for a loss.
— WR Anthony Armstrong caught his and Donovan McNabb’s first touchdown as Redskins.
— RB Keiland Williams showed that he could possibly breakthrough an already crowded backfield to make the final roster.
— CB Ramzee Robinson made several special teams gems. And as always this is what separates young players who make NFL rosters.
— WR Brandon Banks showed the 4.2 speed that has caught the eye of many around the NFL. Banks did not waste any time as he returned a punt 77 yards for a touchdown. His effort should help add greater debate about getting the young speedster more opportunities.
— RB Ryan Torain was impressive with 17 rushes for 62 yards.
— Former Pro Bowl TE Chris Cooley looked comfortable working with McNabb as he produced 3 catches for 33 yards.
— CB DeAngelo Hall had a nice interception, which he returned for 33 yards.
Lake Lewis is the head of the Sports Journey Broadcast Network and their daily drive-time radio host. He also is a credentialed member of the media by the NBA, Washington Redskins, and Baltimore Ravens.
Donovan McNabb’s Washington Debut is a Success by Lloyd Vance
Redskins QB Donovan McNabb had a strong performance in his Washington debut against the Buffalo Bills
After only having one preseason game last week, the NFL exploded this week with a slate of 16 early season battles. One the most anticipated storylines of the 2010 NFL Preseason Week 1 was the debut of 12-year veteran quarterback Donovan McNabb with the Washington Redskins.
The former Eagles starter for 11 years had been performing in training camp to some mixed reviews. But as usual “Game Time” meant that the former 6-time Pro Bowl passer was all business. McNabb gave the Redskins’ faithful something to cheer about as he led Washington to a dominating 42-17 home victory over the hapless Buffalo Bills.
After a couple of errant throws in his first series, the notoriously slow starting McNabb picked-it-up. Big 5 started to look comfortable in his new surroundings on Washington’s second offensive series. And finished with respectable numbers 5 for 8 for 58 passing yards and one rushing yard in two series of work. His biggest play was a 4-yard touchdown to WR Anthony Armstrong.
McNabb said after the lopsided win, “When you play your first game, obviously, with a new ballclub, it takes you back to the first game you played.” The dual-threat passer added, “Your adrenaline is high, and you have to settle down a little bit. The second time we went out, after our first drive, it led to us putting up some points.”
Next up McNabb and the Redskins will face the Baltimore Ravens on August 21 in a territorial bragging rights game. But you know the 33-year old passer is using every game until October 3rd (vs. the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field) as a warm-up.
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
2010 NFL Pre-Training Camp Top Stories – Old Faces in New Places by Lloyd Vance
There was a lot of movement this offseason including some high profile players. Probably the biggest name to switch teams was QB Donovan McNabb going to D.C after 11 years with the Philadelphia Eagles
Every year around the NFL there is one guarantee, “Change”. Whether it is players, assistant coaches, head coaches, or front-office types every NFL team’s roster is constantly changing like an ameba. Fans and media often wonder why teams need so many offseason workouts (OTAs, passing camps, etc). Well… the reason for the increased number of workouts in the offseason is that teams need as much “getting to know you” opportunities as possible to meld so many new faces together in a short period of time. Training camps just are not long enough anymore to get so many new faces on the same page in order to be “competitive” for the upcoming season.
Typically teams have 15 or more new players each season due to retirements, cuts, the draft, and free agency – this year the Washington Redskins lead the way with 20+ new faces including a new general manager (Bruce Allen), head coach Mike Shanahan, and quarterback (Donovan McNabb). Surprisingly after there were 11 new head coaches in 2009, there are only three new head coaches – four if you include Oakland Raiders taking away Tom Cable’s “interim” HC label — for the 2010 NFL Season (Buffalo Bills Chan Gailey, Seattle Seahawks Pete Carroll and Shanahan).
Some bigger names in new places for 2010 are:
Washington Redskins QB Donovan McNabb – The 11-year veteran was traded from the Philadelphia Eagles for a 2nd Rd (37) in 2010 and a 3rd or 4th in 2011. McNabb will be heading down I-95 to help revive the 4-12 Redskins while their division rivals will now turn to Kevin Kolb to be their starter.
Miami Dolphins WR Brandon Marshall – The volatile, but talented pass catcher was traded by the Denver Broncos for 2nd rounders in 2010 and 2011. Marshall also was extended by Miami with the terms four-years, $47.5 million dollars with $24M Guaranteed. It will be interesting to see if the former Broncos perennial 100-catch receiver is fully recovered from off-season hip surgery once training camp starts.
New York Jets WR Santonio Holmes – After being a major P.I.T.A during his time with the Pittsburgh Steelers, the Rooney’s had seen enough. In a total surprise, the Steelers sent their former Super Bowl hero to the NY Jets for a measly 5th round pick in 2010. Even though Holmes will have to serve a 4-game suspension to start the 2010 season, the NY Jets are confident that Braylon Edwards, TE Dustin Keller, and he can form a solid receiving corps for young passer Mark Sanchez.
Chicago Bears DE Julius Peppers – The high-motor sack artist and easily 2010’s Free Agency “Big Fish” was signed by the Bears from Carolina Panthers (six-years, $91.5 million dollar contract with 30M guaranteed). After signing Peppers, the Bears released former starter Alex Brown (signed w/ New Orleans Saints). Chicago is hoping that Peppers is motivated enough to eclipse his 2009 sack total of 10 1/2.
Seattle Seahawks QB Charlie Whitehurst — This former unproven backup was traded by the San Diego Chargers to Seattle. The two teams swapped second-round picks in 2010 and the Seahawks will send a future 3rd RD pick to the Chargers. Seattle then extended Whitehurst with the terms $8M over two years, with another $2M available in incentives.
Chicago Bears RB Chester Taylor – After spending the last couple years as an under-utilized backup to Pro Bowl RB Adrian Peterson, Taylor will be a chance for more carries with the Bears. The Viking unrestricted free agent signed a four-year, $12.5 million dollar contract that contains $7 million in guarantees in the first year. Look for Taylor and 3rd-year back Matt Forte to form a lethal combination backfield like the Panthers’ DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart.
Arizona Cardinals OG Alan Faneca – After the NY Jets decided that this former Pro Bowl player wasn’t needed after drafting some younger players. Former Steelers coaches Ken Whisenhunt and Russ Grimm were more than happy to sign Faneca to help young running back Chris “Beanie” Wells. The 33-year old road grader was signed to a one-year, $2.5 million deal, which included a $300,000 signing bonus and a $100,000 workout bonus.
Arizona Cardinals S Kerry Rhodes – The NY Jets kicked Rhodes out of Rex Ryan’s doghouse by trading him for a 4th in ’10 and a 7th in ’11. The Cardinals were excited to have him to team with Pro Bowler Adrian Wilson as shown by Rhodes’ five-year, $33.5 million extension.
Atlanta Falcons CB Dunta Robinson – Former first round pick was signed from the Houston Texans as an unrestricted free agent (six-year, $57 million dollars, w/ $25.5 million dollars in guarantees). The Falcons are expecting Robinson to play close to NY Jets Pro Bowler Darrelle Revis, who always shadows his opponent’s best receiver.
Baltimore Ravens WR Anquan Boldin – The former multiple-time Pro Bowl receiver was traded along with a 5th Rd selection by the Arizona Cardinals for 3rd and 4th-round picks in the 2010 NFL Draft.
NY Jets RB LaDainian Tomlinson – Signed from the San Diego Chargers after being cut (two-years, $5.2 million contract w/ another $500,000 is available via incentives)
Kansas City Chiefs RB Thomas Jones – After surprisingly being cut, the Chiefs signed the former NY Jets leading rusher with the terms two-years, $5.5M — $3 million dollars this season, $2M in 2011, and has $500,000 incentives)
Other high profile off-season moves:
NY Jets CB Antonio Cromartie (Traded by the Chargers for a 2011 3rd RD pick)
Cleveland Browns Football Czar Mike Holmgren (former Seattle GM/Head Coach and Super Bowl winner with the Packers)
Washington Redskins head coach Mike Shanahan (former Super Bowl-winning head coach for the Denver Broncos)
Detroit Lions OG Rob Sims (Traded from Seattle – 5th Rd in 2010)
Detroit Lions TE Tony Scheffler (Traded by Denver along w/ a seventh-round pick for a 5th Rd in 2010)
Jacksonville Jaguars DE Aaron Kampman (Packers – FA, four-year, $24 million w/ $11 million in the first year)
Baltimore Ravens WR Donte Stallworth (Signed after the Cleveland Browns cut him)
Miami Dolphins LB Karlos Dansby (Cardinals – FA, 5-year, $43 million w/ $22M guaranteed)
Chicago Bears OC Mike Martz (after one year in studio, the “Mad Scientist” returns with a new team and trigger-happy quarterback in Jay Cutler)
Denver Broncos QB Brady Quinn (traded from the Browns to provide competition for Kyle Orton, but Tebow is in the wings)
New England Patriots WR Torry Holt (long-time Rams Pro Bowl receiver left the Jags for New England, 1-yr, $1.7M)
New Orleans Saints DE Alex Brown (Bears – FA, two-year for $6M)
NY Giants DB Antrel Rolle (Cardinals – FA, 5-year, $37 million with $15 million guaranteed)
NY Jets safety Brodney Pool (Browns – FA, one-year, $1.3 million dollar contract)
NY Jets DE/OLB Jason Taylor (former Dolphins leading sacker)
Oakland Raiders DE/OLB Kamerion Wimbley (Traded from the Cleveland Browns for a 3rd RD in 2010)
Pittsburgh Steelers WR Antwaan Randle El (Redskins – cut)
Cincinnati Bengals WR Matt Jones (Signed Street F\A — JAX)
Cincinnati Bengals CB Adam “Pacman” Jones (Cowboys – FA, 2-year deal)
Pittsburgh Steelers LB Larry Foote (Lions — 3-year, $9.3 million w/ $1.8M signing bonus)
Pittsburgh Steelers QB Byron Leftwich (Traded by the Bucs – 7th Rd pick in 2010)
Arizona Cardinals OLB Joey Porter (Signed after being cut by the Dolphins)
Pittsburgh Steelers CB Bryant McFadden (Traded by the Cardinals)
SF 49ers WR/KR Ted Ginn Jr (Traded by the Dolphins for a 5th Rd in 2010)
Seattle Seahawks WR Mike Williams (Signed as a F\A – Last players for Titans in 2007)
Tennessee Titans LB Will Witherspoon (Eagles – FA, three-year, $11M w/ $5M guaranteed)
Washington Redskins OT Jammal Brown (Traded from the Saints)
Denver Broncos QB Tim Tebow (I know this former Heisman winner is a rookie, but he already was a houehold name after being college football’s Superman for 4 years)
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
McNabb Traded to the Redskins for Picks by Lloyd Vance
Quarterback Donovan McNabb will now be throwing passes for the Washington Redskins as the Philadelphia Eagles traded him for picks on Sunday
Well it finally happened… the Philadelphia Eagles decided that on Easter Sunday 2010, that the Kevin Kolb era should officially begin. The Eagles shipped franchise quarterback Donovan McNabb (33) to the Washington Redskins for a 2010 second round pick (37) and a 2011 third or fourth round pick.
The trading of McNabb was not a surprise to me after weeks of very loud anti-Donovan rants within the team’s vocal fanbase and media. The 11-year veteran – who I believe is the most overanalyzed and underappreciated player in Eagles’ history — holds almost every franchise passing record, but more than ever there have been constant cries for Big 5 to pack up his air guitar and leave the ‘City of Brotherly Love’ and now that is the case.
The surprising part of the McNabb trade is that the Birds decided that they did not have a problem shipping their franchise quarterback to an inter-division rival. I guess the Eagles really didn’t care that they will now be facing McNabb twice next season – probably with both games in prime time. And it will be real interesting to see the reception Big 5 receives in Philly and DC.
So now the biggest athlete in Philadelphia for the last 11 years will drive down I-95 to take his place with the hated Redskins. While in Philadelphia, Kolb (career numbers: 79-130, 60.8%, 885 yards, 4 TDs and 7 INTs) is now the Eagles starter and we will see if he is more Norm Van Brocklin than Bobby Hoying in the upcoming season.
But before McNabb leaves town, let’s take a look back. For over a decade in Philadelphia, the name “Donovan McNabb” has been both a lightning rod for both passion and scorn. During this period McNabb has risen to the heights of 6 Pro Bowl appearances and a Super Bowl appearance in the 2004 season. While also facing the depths of boos at the 1999 NFL Draft, coming back from an ACL injury in 2006 and defending his play in four NFC Championship Game losses.
Yes…McNabb, head coach Andy Reid and the Eagles’ organization as a whole have not brought home a Super Bowl Championship in 11 years. However there is no questioning McNabb’s value to the Eagles franchise – respectable career passing numbers: 2801-4746, 59.0% completion rate, 32,873 yards, 216 TDs, and 100 INTs with an additional 3249 yards and 28 touchdowns rushing. Plus starting records of 92-45-1 in the regular season and 9-7 in the playoffs.
So now it will be 4th year quarterback Kolb taking over, but I caution Eagles’ fans to be careful what they wish for. In a past research article that I wrote, most teams after jettisoning their franchise quarterback struggle in their first season without their deposed passer. The study showed, Season 1 can tend to get tough as 26 teams in their first season without their franchise passer had a combined regular season record of 170-221-5 (winning percentage of 43%) with 16 losing records, 6 playoff teams, and zero Conference Champions or Super Bowl Champions.
Thankfully for the classy McNabb, his trade saga is over and he and the Eagles can start over. The Birds are armed with 11 picks in the upcoming draft and the Redskins are eager to move-on with their new franchise passer.
But I have a feeling that Eagles’ fans may soon be learning that the grass is not so much greener on the other side. And a friendly reminder will be on their opponent’s sidelines when they play the Redskins twice in 2010.
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
Life after McNabb maybe tougher on the Eagles than expected by Lloyd Vance
If the Eagles do decide to move-on without Donovan McNabb, history has shown some interesting results once a franchise quarterback leaves a team, especially in Season 1
The Philadelphia Eagles are indeed shopping franchise quarterback Donovan McNabb hard, with a team senior official saying via ESPN “We continue to engage in conversations with multiple teams that initially contacted us”. So for all intents and purposes the biggest athlete in Philadelphia for the last 11 years appears to be on his way out the door.
The proverbial horse has left the barn, leaving only a slim chance that McNabb will not be traded and return for the 2010 season. The news of an impending trade — possibly by Draft Day (April 22) or before when McNabb’s roster bonus of $6.2 million is due on May 5th — probably has put a smile on the growing list of Eagles’ fans and media that are ready to move on from the franchise’s most decorated passer.
For over a decade in Philadelphia, the name “Donovan McNabb” has been both a lightning rod for both passion and scorn. During this period McNabb has risen to the heights of 5 Pro Bowl selections and a Super Bowl appearance in the 2004 season. While also facing the depths of boos at the 1999 NFL Draft, coming back from an ACL injury in 2006 and defending his play in four NFC Championship Game losses. McNabb – who I believe is the most overanalyzed and underappreciated player in Eagles’ history — holds almost every franchise passing record, but more than ever there have been cries for Big 5 to pack up his air guitar and leave the City of Brotherly Love.
Fans and media that want the 33-year old passer to leave, so that younger quarterback Kevin Kolb (career numbers: 79-130, 60.8%, 885 yards, 4 TDs and 7 INTs) can take over the reins seem to have reoccurring gripes about their soon to be former leader. Recently radio stations and message boards have been flooded with “negative” McNabb talk.
I wonder if some of these comments sound familiar — “McNabb throws worm balls”; “The National Media has no idea, just how bad McNabb really is”; “McNabb is inaccurate causing him to not hit receivers in stride”; “McNabb has lost 4 NFC Championship Games, two of which were at home and three where the Eagles were favored”; “McNabb smiles after interceptions”; “McNabb never scrambles anymore because he doesn’t want to be labeled a running quarterback”; “McNabb cannot win big games”; “McNabb should change his name to McChoke”; “McNabb caused the Birds to lose the last game at the Vet”; “McNabb is too injury prone” and “McNabb blew-it in the Super Bowl against the Patriots”. These are just the tip of the iceberg as public sentiment in Philadelphia clearly seems to want the team to start the Kolb era immediately.
However as someone that has probably seen every snap of the McNabb era, I want to offer some caution on letting go a quarterback of No. 5’s ilk. ESPN analyst Chris Mortensen recently said of the whole McNabb is on the trading block hysteria of the past few weeks, “Quarterbacks of (McNabb’s) caliber just aren’t traded in the NFL”.
Yes…McNabb, head coach Andy Reid and the Eagles’ organization as a whole have not brought home a Super Bowl Championship in 11 years. And their 2009 end of season losses against the Cowboys were embarrassing. With McNabb definitely deserving some of the blame for his team’s humiliating 38-14 loss to the Cowboys in the Wildcard Round — numbers of 19/37, 230 YDS, 1 TD, 1 INT and 1 lost fumble.
But you cannot forget McNabb’s value to the Eagles franchise in the community (does the rights things) and on the field over 11 years –respectable career passing numbers: 2801-4746, 59.0% completion rate, 32,873 yards, 216 TDs, and 100 INTs – NFL record for touchdown-to-interception ratio — an additional 3249 yards and 28 touchdowns rushing. Plus starting records of 92-45-1 in the regular season and 9-7 in the playoffs. But with public sentiment leaning towards McNabb leaving, I put my “Ray Didinger” researcher’s hat on in hopes of looking at how teams fared after turning the page from their franchise quarterback of many years.
I took a historical sample of 26 teams who had a franchise quarterback leave and how they fared afterwards (ex. SF 49ers Joe Montana, Tennessee Titans Steve McNair, Minnesota Vikings Fran Tarkenton, and others). I went as far back as 1959 in looking at how the Detroit Lions picked up the pieces after starter Bobby Layne was traded to the Pittsburgh Steelers during the 1958 season. The quarterbacks that I selected had been a consistent starter for their teams for over 5 years – except Sonny Jurgensen, who was a 3-year starter for the Eagles – then left their teams via retirement, trade, or release.
The key categories of measurement were the former quarterback’s team record and playoff status in their last season before they were jettisoned and the team’s regular season records and playoff status in the next 3 seasons without their deposed franchise quarterback. The results varied, but there is one trend that the Eagles and their disgruntled fanbase should analyze and that is the first season after a franchise quarterback has left.
The 26 quarterbacks’ teams had a combined regular season record of 199-192-5 in the last season before their franchise signal caller left with 11 losing records and a winning percentage of 50%. Of those 26 teams in their franchise quarterback’s last season, ten were playoff teams and two were Super Champions.
Season 1 after a franchise passer leaves shows that things can tend to gettougher. The 26 teams in their first season without their franchise passer had a combined regular season record of 170-221-5 (winning percentage of 43%) with 16 losing records, 6 playoff teams, and zero Conference Champions or Super Bowl Champions.
Season 2 after a franchise passer showed a more upward trend. The 26 teams in their second season without their franchise passer had a combined regular season record of 227-170-1 (winning percentage of 57%) with 7 losing records, 16 playoff teams, 1 Conference Champion and two Super Bowl Champions.
Season 3 after a franchise passer showed a slight downward trend, but a better winning percentage than the last season with the franchise quarterback. The 26 teams in their third season without their franchise passer had a combined regular season record of 221-175-4 (winning percentage of 55%) with 11 losing records, 9 playoff teams, zero Conference Champions, and 2 Super Bowl Championships.
We will see just how long the “McNabb Trade” saga takes to finally play out. But these statistics show that sometimes the grass is not so much greener on the other side. Remember the Eagles were an 11-5 playoff team and scored a franchise-record 429 points in 2009 with McNabb.
Lloyd Vance is a Sr. NFL Writer for Taking It to the House and Sports Journey Network , who is also an award-winning member of the Pro Football Writers of America (PFWA)
www.sportsjourney.com 
